2021 ESA Annual Meeting (August 2 - 6)

SYMP 8 Can Nucleation Bridge to Desirable Alternative Stable States? Theory and Applications

2:30 PM-3:30 PM
Session Organizer:
Theo Michaels
Moderator:
James D. Bever, PhD
Volunteer:
Molly Reichenborn, M.Sc.
Ecosystem recovery is full of wicked problems. These problems arise from the complexity of interactions within a system which create feedbacks and nonlinear responses to management interventions. This in turn, can give rise to unintended consequences, including degraded alternative stable states. Degraded alternative stable states may resist restoration practices that simply try to recreate historic abiotic conditions. Instead, the re-establishment of functional ecosystem states may depend upon overcoming resistance thresholds (Suding et al. 2004). Despite the conceptual utility of the alternate stable state framework, it has offered few strategies to lower the barriers created by these resistance thresholds. Therefore, the intentional manipulation of ecosystems from one alternative stable state to another remains a critical challenge to management practices. Ecological nucleation is an emerging framework by which to address alternative stable states and promote ecosystem recovery. Nucleation is a process by which an initial patch of a desired state reaches a critical radius that lowers resistance thresholds and catalyzes rapid growth through local positive feedback dynamics. In this way, nucleation embodies vital connections between local scale interactions and landscape scale transitions between alternate stable states. By focusing on local interactions that can initialize an autocatalytic process that spreads in space, application of nucleation theory provides a promising way forward to boost the effectiveness of future management interventions related to alternative stable states that arise from anthropogenic disturbances. The goals of this symposium are to 1) present the ecological theory behind nucleation as it relates to alternative stable states, 2) demonstrate how nucleation can be leveraged to promote ecological recovery, and 3) to promote discussion about future research needs. This symposium will first provide participants with an in-depth look at the ecological underpinnings of nucleation. With this foundation and common vocabulary, we will then explore three detailed examples of nucleation in forest, grassland and salt marsh systems. Each of these examples will show direct connections to nucleation dynamics and demonstrate how nucleation can be leveraged to promote ecosystem recovery.
On Demand
Implications of patch-size dependent feedbacks for the recovery of salt marshes and coastal dunes
Christine Angelini, Environmental Engineering Sciences, University of Florida;
On Demand
Introducing desirable patches: A nuclear option for ecosystem restoration?
Maarten B. Eppinga, Department of Geography, University of Zürich;
On Demand
Scaling up spatially-patterned planting methods to restore tropical forest
Karen D. Holl, University of California, Santa Cruz;
On Demand
What’s so positive about positive feedback? Leveraging nucleation dynamics to enhance restoration in tallgrass prairie systems
Theo Michaels, Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Kansas;