OOS 30 - Managing Ecological Systems at Multiple Scales: The Role of Institutions and Stakeholder Interactions

Friday, August 16, 2019: 8:00 AM-11:30 AM
M107, Kentucky International Convention Center
Organizer:
Paul R. Armsworth
Co-organizer:
Michael G. Neubert
Moderator:
Louis Gross
How can ecological systems be efficiently managed at different scales? Data to understand the variation of management practices and to quantify interactions and linkages among ecosystems are increasing in both their resolution and coverage at an unprecedented rate. But ecosystem management is only partly about understanding ecological dynamics. It is also about accounting for human interests, and communities vary in what they want from ecological systems and how they interact with those systems at different spatial scales. The use of fine-grained management strategies allows policy-makers to incorporate socio-ecological heterogeneity more precisely. But doing so risks organizations designing strategies in a piecemeal, site-by-site fashion that fails to account for spatial interactions and feedbacks between components of larger ecological and social systems. Moreover, implementing fine-grained management entails higher administrative costs than most management agencies are willing to bear. On the other hand, acting over broad spatial scales can obscure ecological heterogeneity and disconnects policy-makers from local resource users, which undermines management effectiveness. To balance this trade-off, conservation organizations often try to work over large spatial scales, while embedding institutional hierarchies in order to resolve ecological dynamics more finely and to better incorporate the actions and needs of local communities. In this interdisciplinary session, we will examine how best to apportion responsibility for managing ecological systems among natural resource management agencies and conservation organizations working over different scales. Speakers will present innovations in optimization methods that can be used to design management interventions that better reflect the institutional layering of the different actors involved. They will illustrate the underlying theories and methodologies with applications to marine fisheries, invasive species management, epidemiology, biodiversity conservation, and the management of recreation and hunting pressure. Applications will span developing- and developed-world contexts and include data from the nearby Appalachian region as well as tropical regions at the deforestation frontier. Some speakers will examine whether state or federal governments are better positioned to manage ecological systems; others will examine behavior of conservation NGOs. Some will downscale and examine how best to account for local resource users in regional management plans. The session will showcase how ecological models and data can be integrated using approaches fromenvironmental law, economics, mathematics and computer science and will include speakers from each of these disciplines. Key advances that will be presented in the session include combining game theory and metapopulation dynamics, bi-level optimization and biodiversity data, externality theory and epidemiological modeling.
8:00 AM
The law and policy of cooperative conservation
Joshua U. Galperin, University of Pittsburgh
8:20 AM
Overcoming institutional hurdles to development of quantitative decision support
Gwenllian D. Iacona, Arizona State University; Stephanie Avery-Gomm, University of Queensland; Richard Maloney, Department of Conservation; Christina Drew, KDV Decision Analysis LLC; Michael C. Runge, US Geological Survey; Deborah Crouse, US Fish and Wildlife Service; Jeff Newman, 6 US Fish and Wildlife Service; Don Morgan, US Fish and Wildlife Service; Hugh P. Possingham, The Nature Conservancy; Leah R. Gerber, Arizona State University
9:00 AM
Transboundary fisheries management: The effects of decentralization, dispersal, and interstate competition
James N. Sanchirico, University of California-Davis; Julie C. Blackwood, Williams College; Ben Fitzpatrick, Loyala Marymount University; David Kling, Oregon State University; Suzanne Lenhart, University of Tennessee; Michael G. Neubert, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution; Katriona Shea, The Pennsylvania State University; Charles Sims, University of Tennessee, Knoxville
9:20 AM
Local versus global governance of disease outbreaks and invader spread
Suzanne Lenhart, University of Tennessee; Julie C. Blackwood, Williams College; Ben Fitzpatrick, Loyala Marymount University; Michael Springborn, University of California, Davis; David Kling, Oregon State University; Charles Sims, University of Tennessee, Knoxville; Christina Edholm, U of Tennessee; Katriona Shea, The Pennsylvania State University
9:40 AM
9:50 AM
A policy perspective on conservation planning.
Jorge Soberon, Biodiversity Institute, University of Kansas
10:10 AM
Putting people into park design
Heidi J. Albers, University of Wyoming; Charlotte H. Chang, National Institute for Mathematical and Biological Synthesis, University of Tennessee; Sahan T. M. Dissayanake, Portland State University; Kate J. Helmstedt, Queensland University of Technology; Kailin Kroetz, Resources for the Future; Christoph Nolte, Boston University; Gwen Spencer, Smith College
10:30 AM
Accounting for institutional structure in spatial conservation planning
Paul R. Armsworth, University of Tennessee; Amy Benefield, University of Colorado; Bistra Dilkina, University of Southern California; Joseph E. Fargione, The Nature Conservancy; Maria Fisher, The Nature Conservancy; Rachel Fovargue, University of Oklahoma; Xingli Giam, University of Tennessee, Knoxville; Jamal Harris, The Nature Conservancy; Kate J. Helmstedt, Queensland University of Technology; Heather Bird Jackson, University of Tennessee; Kailin Kroetz, Resources for the Future; Diane Le Bouille, University of Tennessee; Christoph Nolte, Boston University; Leticia Ochoa-Ochoa, Facultad de Ciencias, UNAM; Monica Papes, University of Tennessee; Arne Pinnschmidt, Wageningen University; Charles Sims, University of Tennessee, Knoxville
10:50 AM Cancelled
OOS 30-9
Spatiotemporal variation in the efficacy of siting protected areas (widthdrawn)
Xingli Giam, University of Tennessee, Knoxville; Paul R. Armsworth, University of Tennessee; Luis Carrasco, University of Tennessee; Rachel Fovargue, University of Oklahoma; Christoph Nolte, Boston University; Monica Papes, University of Tennessee